“My soul: “Who gives you thoughts and words? Do you make them? Are you not my serf, a recipient who lies at my door and picks up my alms? And you dare think that what you devise and speak could be nonsense? Don’t you know yet that it comes from me and belongs to me?”
So I cried full of anger, “But then my indignation must also come from you, and in me you are indignant against yourself.” My soul then spoke the ambiguous words: “That is civil war.”
~ C.G. Jung, The Red Book, Ch.II
There are moments when I feel seized by a thought, a word, a mood – something that comes with the full force of conviction, as if it were my own, as it is me. I might sit to write, speak to a friend, go on a walk – and a phrase will arise that moves me in its clarity and force. I used to think this was simply me being inspired. Later I began to wonder: who is the one inspiring? where are those ideas and emotions come from?
Jung’s dialogue with the soul shook me the first time I read it. It suggested that what I call “my thoughts” may not, in fact, be mine at all. That I, in my conscious position, am the recipient and not the source. And the soul? She is the giver. I receive what she allows me to carry.
This realization is shocking when one encounters it for the first time. If one is able to consider the truth in it, and not run away from this possibility, one is humbled. It is the starting point of a conscious relationship with the source of those inner experiences.

I remember a time during a creative drought, when I felt barren. Nothing I wrote felt alive. I questioned my voice, path, sense of self. Each word I wrote felt like a pale imitation of what I want to express. A lie. I found myself angry at the silence, the blockage, myself.
And then a strange thing happened: I turned the anger inward and demanded, “Why have you abandoned me?”
And something in me answered: “Do you think you can demand what is not yours?”
It hit like a cold wind. The very force of my frustration revealed its origin. It, too, came from the soul. My rebellion, protest, and doubt – even these belonged to Her.
And with that, I felt the paradox Jung names so clearly: the soul giving and receiving from herself, through the vessel of my limited human self. A civil war. One part of me fighting another, while both claiming to be the one who holds the truth, both animated by the same deep force that moves through me but is not of my making.
The inner split is real.
There’s a part of me that trusts the mystery, and another that insists on knowing.
One wants to serve, and another resists with everything it has.
One speaks with conviction, and one shrinks back, afraid of being truly seen.
Whenever I sit down to write or turn inward, they’re all there.
At times they argue. Other times they grieve.
And sometimes, they just sit together in silence.
But here is the shift I’m learning to make: not to side with one voice over another, but to listen to all of them. To recognize that the war itself is part of the individuation process. That the soul does not move in straight lines. She moves in spirals, contradictions, ironies, paradoxes, and tensions that cannot be resolved without suffering and effort, if ever.
The ideal of ending the war is replaced with holding the battlefield as sacred. To become a witness to the struggle, without trying to silence it, numb it, ignore it, run away from it.
To allow what comes to come – not because I understand it, but because it lives in me.
So today, I bow my head before the mystery that moves through me. I do not claim authorship. I want to participate. I offer my hands, my voice, my attention, my time, my resistance – as vessels of a larger dialogue, for a hidden and open process of transformation, personal and collective.



Leave a Reply